Safety

Safest Cities in Wisconsin: 10 Places Where Crime Stays Low

On this page
  1. 01TLDR
  2. 02The 10 safest cities in Wisconsin
  3. 03Side-by-side comparison
  4. 04Why the rankings disagree
  5. 05Safest larger cities in Wisconsin
  6. 06What living in these places is like
  7. 07Small-agency reporting quirks
  8. 08FAQ

If you search for the safest cities in Wisconsin, you get four lists and four different winners. SafeWise puts Hobart-Lawrence first. HomeSnacks picks Evansville. AreaVibes also leads with Hobart. OpenCrime sorts by violent crime alone. They all draw on FBI data, and they still disagree.

This list settles it by cross-referencing them. A city ranks higher here if it shows up on several lists, then by how low its violent crime runs. Each entry also covers what the rankings skip: how far you are from Milwaukee or Madison, what housing tends to cost, and what daily life looks like.

Contents

TLDR

  • Safest overall: Hobart-Lawrence, Oconomowoc, Oregon and Kronenwetter appear on three of the four lists we checked.
  • Safest near Madison: Oregon, Waunakee and Mount Horeb.
  • Safest near Milwaukee: Oconomowoc, Hartland and Cedarburg.
  • Safest near Green Bay: Hobart-Lawrence.
  • Safest large-ish city: Verona, Brookfield and Middleton beat Madison, Appleton and Green Bay on violent crime by a wide margin.
  • Data year: FBI figures for 2024, the most recent full year available across these sources.

The 10 safest cities in Wisconsin

A picturesque village nestled among lush green hills under a clear blue sky.

Rates below are per 100,000 residents, drawn from FBI 2024 data as published by SafeWise, HomeSnacks, AreaVibes and OpenCrime. Populations come from the same sources and differ slightly between them.

1. Hobart-Lawrence (Brown County)

Population around 18,000. Violent crime runs about 44 per 100,000 and property crime about 227. It tops the SafeWise ranking of 111 Wisconsin cities and sits in the top six on HomeSnacks and AreaVibes.

One wrinkle: SafeWise and HomeSnacks list Hobart and Lawrence as a combined 18,035-person entry, while AreaVibes lists Hobart alone at 9,770 with identical crime rates. Same police data, different population denominator in the label. It’s a Green Bay suburb, so you get big-city jobs and stadium-weekend traffic a short drive away without the big-city crime numbers.

2. Oconomowoc (Waukesha County)

Population about 18,800. The violent crime rate is roughly 16 per 100,000, which works out to around three incidents in a year. Property crime is about 308 per 100,000. It’s the only city that is top three on SafeWise and HomeSnacks and top seven on AreaVibes.

Oconomowoc sits on a chain of lakes, about 30 miles west of Milwaukee. Fowler Lake sits right downtown. Expect lake-town prices, and a commute that’s workable on I-94 but not short.

3. Oregon (Dane County)

Population about 11,800. Violent crime is about 42 per 100,000 and property crime about 279. Oregon appears on three of the four lists.

It’s a village roughly 15 miles south of Madison, which makes it the cleanest answer for someone who works in Madison and wants a small-town street grid. The Oregon School District is a big part of why families settle here.

4. Kronenwetter (Marathon County)

Population about 8,600. Violent crime is about 47 per 100,000, property crime about 268. Kronenwetter is the central Wisconsin pick, a village just south of Wausau along the Wisconsin River corridor.

If you want low crime without a Madison or Milwaukee price tag, this is where the lists point. Wausau supplies the hospital system, employers and shopping.

5. Evansville (Rock County)

Population about 5,900. Zero violent crime in the HomeSnacks data, and a property rate of about 273 per 100,000. HomeSnacks ranks it first in the state and AreaVibes second, though it misses SafeWise’s top 10.

Evansville is the smallest city here, and that cuts both ways: a zero is easier to hit when a handful of incidents would change the number. It has a large historic district of 19th-century homes and sits about 25 miles southeast of Madison, with Janesville and Beloit closer to the south.

6. Waunakee (Dane County)

Population about 15,200. Violent crime is about 105 per 100,000, property crime about 210. It’s fifth on both SafeWise and AreaVibes.

Waunakee is a commuter village roughly 10 miles northwest of downtown Madison and one of the most expensive towns on this list. It trades a slightly higher violent rate than the top four for school reputation and proximity to the capital.

7. Mount Horeb (Dane County)

Population about 7,750. Violent crime is about 116 per 100,000, property crime about 168. SafeWise puts it sixth and AreaVibes third.

The village, about 20 miles west of Madison, calls itself the Troll Capital of the World, and the downtown trolls are real. Its violent rate bounces: SafeWise’s figures for the three years it shows swing between about 10 and 120 per 100,000. That’s what a small denominator does.

8. Hartland (Waukesha County)

Population about 10,300. Violent crime is about 68 per 100,000, property crime about 341. It is eighth on SafeWise and ninth on AreaVibes.

Hartland sits on Pewaukee Lake, about 25 miles west of downtown Milwaukee. It’s a lake-and-commuter village: the Waukesha County suburbs are among the safest in the state and also among the priciest.

9. Cedarburg (Ozaukee County)

Population about 12,600. SafeWise’s rates for Cedarburg are roughly 50 violent and 400 property crimes per 100,000. It ranks seventh there.

Cedarburg is about 20 miles north of Milwaukee and has an intact 19th-century downtown, including the last original covered bridge in Wisconsin. It’s the safest pick for people who work in Milwaukee’s north side or downtown and want a quick drive in.

10. Holmen (La Crosse County)

Population about 11,900. SafeWise’s figures are roughly 50 violent and 470 property crimes per 100,000, tenth in the state ranking.

Holmen is a Mississippi River valley village a short drive north of La Crosse. It’s the western Wisconsin entry, with housing costs well under Madison and Milwaukee suburbs and the Coulee Region’s bluffs and trails nearby.

Near misses

Elm Grove, Bloomfield, Caledonia, Berlin, Grand Rapids and Geneva Town each show up on one list’s top 10 but not the others, so they missed the cut. Elm Grove (a Milwaukee-area village) posts zero violent crime on HomeSnacks but a property rate near 500 per 100,000.

Side-by-side comparison

Black and white image of New York City's iconic skyline featuring classic architecture.
City County Population Violent / 100k Property / 100k Rough distance to nearest big city
Hobart-Lawrence Brown ~18,000 44 227 Adjacent to Green Bay
Oconomowoc Waukesha ~18,800 16 308 ~30 mi to Milwaukee
Oregon Dane ~11,800 42 279 ~15 mi to Madison
Kronenwetter Marathon ~8,600 47 268 Adjacent to Wausau
Evansville Rock ~5,900 0 273 ~25 mi to Madison
Waunakee Dane ~15,200 105 210 ~10 mi to Madison
Mount Horeb Dane ~7,750 116 168 ~20 mi to Madison
Hartland Waukesha ~10,300 68 341 ~25 mi to Milwaukee
Cedarburg Ozaukee ~12,600 ~50 ~400 ~20 mi to Milwaukee
Holmen La Crosse ~11,900 ~50 ~470 Adjacent to La Crosse

Why the rankings disagree

Four things drive the differences.

Different years. Some lists pull the latest FBI release, others a prior one. AreaVibes says only “most recent release” without naming a year.

Different cutoffs. HomeSnacks counts Wisconsin cities above 5,000 residents, which leaves 134. AreaVibes uses 5,000 or more. SafeWise ranks 111 cities. OpenCrime covers 318. A smaller town that makes one list may not be eligible for another.

Different metrics. HomeSnacks averages a violent-crime rank and a property-crime rank into a safety index. AreaVibes sorts by total crime. OpenCrime’s headline figure is the violent rate alone. A city with almost no violence but plenty of shoplifting can rank first on one and fifth on another. The national picture splits the same way; see how the US safest-city rankings compare.

Different handling of incomplete reporting. SafeWise only includes agencies that submitted complete NIBRS reports and doesn’t estimate missing data. Others take the FBI summary figures as they are. The FBI itself cautions against ranking communities from raw crime numbers, since the figures don’t capture local factors like commuter populations or tourism. You can explore the underlying numbers in the FBI’s Crime Data Explorer.

The lists also contain typos and internal inconsistencies. HomeSnacks gives Oconomowoc’s violent rate as 15 in one place and 16 in another. Treat every figure here as approximate, and treat the cities that appear on multiple lists as the real signal.

Safest larger cities in Wisconsin

Aerial photo capturing an intersection in a suburban neighborhood with houses and greenery.

A town of 6,000 won’t have the jobs, hospitals or restaurants many people need. Here is how Wisconsin’s bigger cities compare on violent crime, using OpenCrime’s FBI 2024 figures. Property crime rates aren’t published on that page for these cities, so this is a violent-crime view only.

City Population Violent / 100k OpenCrime rank (of 318)
Verona ~16,400 49 106
Brookfield ~42,000 83 155
Middleton ~23,400 107 179
Waukesha ~70,200 114 189
Eau Claire ~70,900 162 223
Sun Prairie ~38,500 184 234
Appleton ~74,400 202 245
Wauwatosa ~47,000 207 247
Madison ~282,000 256 276
Fitchburg ~32,700 275 280
Green Bay ~105,200 495 307
Milwaukee ~560,400 1,431 317

Three takeaways:

  • Verona is the standout. At about 16,000 people and a rate under 50 per 100,000, it’s the safest community here with real city amenities. It’s a Madison suburb.
  • Brookfield and Waukesha show that Milwaukee’s western suburbs keep violent crime low even at populations of 40,000 to 70,000. Waukesha is nearly the size of Eau Claire and Appleton and posts a lower rate than both.
  • Madison, Green Bay and Milwaukee are the cities, and city-level numbers hide huge neighborhood variation. Madison’s rate is modest for its size, but the safer suburbs ring it. For the other end of the state, see the 10 most dangerous cities in Wisconsin.

What living in these places is like

Commutes. The Dane County picks (Oregon, Waunakee, Mount Horeb) and Verona put you 10 to 20 miles from downtown Madison. Oconomowoc, Hartland and Cedarburg are 20 to 30 miles from Milwaukee. Hobart-Lawrence, Kronenwetter and Holmen are next to their regional employment centers (Green Bay, Wausau, La Crosse), so a commute there is minutes rather than an hour on the interstate.

Housing. In general, the Waukesha and Dane County suburbs sit at the expensive end, and the central Wisconsin and Mississippi Valley picks are cheaper. A low crime rate and high prices travel together here: the safest big suburbs are the places that tend to cost the most. The Census Bureau’s QuickFacts for Wisconsin gives statewide home value and income baselines to compare against.

Schools. The Dane County villages are known for strong school districts, which is part of why they fill up with families. For any specific town, check the district’s own report card on the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction site instead of relying on a ranking list.

Best for families. Oregon, Waunakee and Oconomowoc combine low crime with a full range of school options and youth sports.

Best for retirees. Cedarburg and Oconomowoc offer walkable downtowns, and Holmen and Kronenwetter give access to La Crosse and Wausau hospitals at lower prices.

Best small towns. Evansville, Mount Horeb and Kronenwetter are the options under 9,000 people. They’re also the most volatile in the data.

Small-agency reporting quirks

Several of these towns have fewer than 10,000 residents. In a town of 6,000, a single violent incident adds about 17 per 100,000 to the rate. That’s why Evansville can show a 0 one year, and why Mount Horeb’s rate swings from near zero to above 100 across consecutive years.

Two other quirks matter:

  • Shared departments and merged entities. Hobart-Lawrence appears under different names and populations on different sites.
  • The NIBRS transition. The FBI’s move to the incident-based reporting system left some agencies with incomplete submissions in recent years. Some lists drop those agencies, others don’t.

A good rule: look at three years of data, not one, and treat a spread of under 50 per 100,000 on violent crime as noise for towns this size.

FAQ

What is the safest city in Wisconsin?

It depends on the list. SafeWise ranks Hobart-Lawrence first, HomeSnacks ranks Evansville first. Hobart-Lawrence, Oconomowoc, Oregon and Kronenwetter appear on three of the four rankings we checked, so they’re the safest-bet answers.

What are the safest small towns in Wisconsin?

Evansville, Mount Horeb, Kronenwetter and Hartland are among the smallest on the lists, all with fewer than 11,000 residents. Remember that very small populations produce volatile rates.

What are the safest cities in Wisconsin to raise a family?

Oregon, Waunakee, Oconomowoc and Verona combine low crime with strong school districts and suburban amenities. Check district report cards before you buy.

What are the safest suburbs near Milwaukee?

Oconomowoc, Hartland and Cedarburg are the top three on our list. Brookfield (about 42,000 people, 83 violent crimes per 100,000) is the safest sizable suburb.

What are the safest cities in Wisconsin for retirees?

Cedarburg, Oconomowoc and Holmen are good starting points: low crime plus a short drive to a regional hospital. Compare housing costs and winter driving before you decide.

Is Madison safe?

Madison’s violent crime rate is about 256 per 100,000 in OpenCrime’s 2024 data. That’s higher than the suburbs around it, but far lower than Milwaukee’s and well below Green Bay’s.

Which Wisconsin city has the lowest crime rate?

Evansville recorded zero violent crimes in HomeSnacks’ FBI 2024 data, and Oconomowoc posted about 16 per 100,000 among cities over 18,000. Both are very low. In a town this small, one extra incident would change the ranking.